Paul O’Connor, Head of the UK-based Multi-Asset Team, considers the potential impact on global economic growth as concerns grow about the spread of the COVID-19 coronavirus beyond China.
- While the daily growth rate of confirmed cases has fallen, attention has turned towards recent flare-ups in other countries, fuelling worry that the coronavirus has broken out on
a number of new regional fronts.
- Consensus expectations have focused on a ‘v’-shaped recovery in global growth, based
on the anticipation of relatively swift containment of the virus. The broadening geographic spread of the virus raises many questions about this milder scenario.
- Given the general unpredictability, it seems right to emphasise capital preservation and defensive strategies until the fog of uncertainty begins to lift.
It seems somewhat paradoxical that financial investors have panicked over the COVID-19 coronavirus, just as the daily growth rate in the number of confirmed cases of the illness drops to its lowest rate since the epidemic began (see exhibit 1). In fact, daily recoveries from the illness have exceeded new infections throughout the past week, so the number of active cases globally has now actually fallen for eight consecutive days.
Exhibit 1: COVID-19 cases globally
Source: www.worldmeter.info, as at 25 February 2020.
Given that 96% of confirmed cases of the virus have been in China, developments there explain most of these recent trends. The aggressive containment measures taken in Hubei province seem to have been fairly effective in containing the spread within China, so far. Indeed, the number of confirmed cases in the rest of China has almost stabilised over the past week, growing at less than one per cent a day. While these recent trends are undoubtedly encouraging, there is a clear possibility that the return to work of an estimated 180 million migrant workers in February and March could still cause a meaningful resurgence of the virus within China.
Coronavirus goes global
It the progress of the virus in China has eased in recent weeks, concerns have now shifted towards recent flare-ups in other countries, most notably Italy, Iran and South Korea. The worry here is that COVID-19 has now broken out on a number of new regional fronts and is potentially building enough momentum to become a global pandemic. Given that the number of cases outside of China and cruise ships is relatively small – at just over 2,200 globally – such fears might seem excessive. However, it is troubling nevertheless that these more recent outbreaks have developed very rapidly (see exhibit 2) and, in some cases, have already seeded new infections in other countries. Furthermore, given that some of the aggressive techniques used to contain the epidemic in China are likely to be considered less acceptable in other countries, efforts to contain new outbreaks may not be as effective as the Chinese experience.
Exhibit 2: COVID-19 cases outside of China
Source: www.worldmeter.info, as at 25 February 2020.
One specific area of concern is the potential for the virus to spread particularly rapidly in countries that have limited resources for healthcare, low levels of virus testing and inadequate disease management. The latest flare-up in Iran is an example that appears to have at least some of these characteristics. Authorities seem to have been slow to respond to the outbreak of the coronavirus and medical staff in Iran have expressed concerns about the availability of appropriate medical equipment. In recent days, Kuwait, Bahrain, Oman and Iraq have all reported new coronavirus cases involving people who had been to Iran. Widespread disquiet about the Iranian regime’s ability to handle the contagion has seen a number of neighbouring countries closing land borders, ceasing flights and imposing restrictions on trade.
’V’-shaped recovery at risk
With the global situation remaining highly fluid, it is impossible to make any meaningful estimate of the full potential impact of the coronavirus on the global economy right now. When the virus was largely contained to China, consensus expectations were generally focused on a ‘v’-shaped recovery in global growth, based on the anticipation of relatively swift containment of the virus and an energetic policy response. The broadening geographic spread of the virus raises many questions about this milder scenario, given the uncertainties surrounding both the effectiveness of containment measures and the scale of the policy response expected in most countries outside China.
Investor concern about the economic impact of COVID-19 is likely to remain closely linked to its geographical progress. If the virus continues to spread internationally, then consensus expectations will shift from a ‘v’-shaped recovery to a deeper and more protracted setback for the global economy. Given that many indicators of positioning and sentiment were showing signs of widespread investor complacency just last week, it is hard to conclude that financial markets are now fully braced for the growth downgrades and the corporate earnings misses that could accompany such a scenario. Given recent trends in the virus, and the general unpredictability of its future progress, it seems right to emphasise capital preservation and defensive strategies until the fog of uncertainty begins to lift, or until markets have repriced sufficiently to offer better risk/returns opportunities. This may take quite some time yet. Prepare for the worst – hope for the best.