Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility The value of “the gray”: Three ways to rethink the role of AI in advisory practices - Janus Henderson Investors - US Advisor
For Financial Professionals in the US

The value of “the gray”: Three ways to rethink the role of AI in advisory practices

As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes more capable, the opportunity for advisors may not be choosing between human judgment and technology but rather learning how to use both to navigate the gray areas of their practice. Monika Mikiciuk, Director, Practice Management Consultant, explains.

Nov 19, 2026
7 minute read

Key takeaways:

  • While plenty of tasks in an advisor’s practice are black and white, some of the most consequential work requires them to operate in the gray – where understanding context, competing priorities, and human dynamics is essential.
  • It would be tempting to conclude that this gray area is where technology’s role ends and the human advisor takes over. But when used thoughtfully, AI can help with these more complex functions.
  • The future of advice doesn’t have to be framed as a contest between artificial intelligence and human intelligence; the more useful question may be how each can make the other better.

I recently wrapped up a day in New York City meeting with financial advisors and teams and talking about one of my favorite topics: How we can use artificial intelligence to amplify human intelligence.

So, naturally, I ended the day by getting a massage from a robot.

I had been seeing advertisements for robotic massages and was curious enough to try one. After a full day of meetings, the timing felt almost too perfect.

The experience was fascinating. Robotic arms performed the massage, while a screen allowed me to adjust the pressure and skip an area if I wanted the machine to move on. In many ways, it was remarkably sophisticated. But there were moments when the robot would linger on an area and I would find myself thinking, Okay, that’s enough. You can move on now. Of course, the robot did not know that.

I could use the screen to change certain things, but there was no person checking in with me, observing my response or asking a question that might change what happened next. The technology could respond to the instructions I explicitly provided; what it struggled with was everything in between. In other words, it struggled with the gray.

And somewhere during that experience, I found myself thinking about the conversations I had been having with advisors earlier that day.

Advice happens in the gray

There is plenty of black and white work in an advisory practice. Information needs to be gathered. Meetings need to be prepared for. Data needs to be analyzed. Communications need to be drafted. Yet some of an advisor’s most consequential work does not come with clearly defined inputs and outputs.

A business owner may say she is ready to sell, but what does ready actually mean?

Parents may want to transfer wealth to their children, while quietly holding different opinions about what is fair.

A client may say he is comfortable taking more investment risk, but his behavior during the next significant market decline may tell you something different.

These situations require an advisor to operate in the gray, where understanding context, competing priorities, and human dynamics is essential.

It would be tempting to conclude that this is where technology’s role ends and the human advisor takes over. But I don’t think that’s quite right. In fact, I think this is where the possibilities become more interesting.

A 2024 study by eMoney found that 70% of financial advisors surveyed viewed AI as a tool to support their decision making.1

The findings show that the opportunity for AI extends beyond simply completing tasks faster. Used thoughtfully, it can help us with more complex functions.

Imagine preparing for a meeting with a family whose members have different personalities, communication styles, and priorities. While an advisor could work through that complexity alone, AI could be leveraged as a strategic thinking partner, helping to examine the situation from different perspectives, surface potential assumptions, consider where tension might emerge, and develop questions that could lead to a more productive conversation.

In this scenario, the technology does not remove the gray. In fact, it may help us see more of it.

A thinking partner shouldn’t always agree with you

There is another dimension to this that I find particularly interesting.

Research highlighted by the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy examined whether conversations with large language models could help correct people’s financial misconceptions. The researchers found that an AI system specifically designed to challenge those misconceptions generated a greater shift away from mistaken beliefs than an off-the-shelf large language model. The researchers also cautioned that general-purpose models can reinforce users’ existing beliefs rather than challenge them.2

That finding suggests a more sophisticated way to think about AI in an advisory practice: Perhaps one of the most useful questions we can ask AI isn’t simply, “What do you think?” but rather, “What am I missing?”

We can ask AI to challenge an assumption, examine a situation from another person’s perspective, or identify information we haven’t considered. This does not outsource judgment. Done well, it puts more information and more perspectives in front of the human who ultimately exercises that judgment.

For advisors, that distinction is important: AI might help anticipate the dynamics of a difficult family meeting. Once everyone is sitting around the table, however, new information will emerge. Someone may hesitate before answering. A family member may introduce a concern no one anticipated. The direction of the conversation may change entirely. When these dynamics arise, the AI preparation and the human presence must work together.

Three ways to rethink the role of AI in an advisory practice

1. Expand your thinking, not just your efficiency

Efficiency certainly matters, but measuring AI only by minutes saved may cause us to overlook some of its more interesting applications.

Before a complex client, prospect, or team conversation, consider using AI to explore alternative perspectives, pressure test assumptions, and determine what you may not have considered.

The return on AI does not always have to be a shorter task. Sometimes it may be a better question, a perspective you had not considered, or an assumption you realize needs to be examined.

2. Prepare with AI so you can be more present with people

The complexity of an upcoming conversation is not necessarily a reason to leave AI out of it. In some cases, it may be precisely the reason to bring AI into the preparation.

Think again about that family meeting. An advisor may need to balance different financial priorities, personalities, relationships, and definitions of what constitutes a successful outcome. AI can provide another lens for thinking through those dynamics before the meeting begins.

This does not mean predicting exactly how people will behave or assuming AI’s analysis is correct. It means arriving with more possibilities in mind and more thoughtful questions available.

3. Move from asking for answers to advancing outcomes

There is another evolution underway in how we interact with AI. You may increasingly hear the term agentic AI, which describes AI that is more goal-directed and able to adapt its approach while working toward an outcome.

For advisors, the practical distinction may matter more than the terminology.

Instead of giving AI a single instruction, receiving an answer, and moving on, the more valuable exchange can become iterative.

Consider the family meeting again. An advisor could begin by providing the relevant context and asking AI to explore the competing priorities. The advisor might then ask what assumptions could be influencing the analysis, introduce additional information about one family member, and ask how that new context should change the preparation.

That is fundamentally different from treating AI like a search box.

The goal is not to let AI make the judgment. It is to arrive at the moment of judgment better prepared.

Finding value in the gray

I’m glad I tried the robot massage. It was a memorable experience, and I would probably do it again.

But it also gave me a different perspective on conversations I had been having all day.

The future of advice does not have to be framed as a contest between artificial intelligence and human intelligence. Increasingly, the more useful question may be how each can make the other better.

For an industry built around helping people make consequential decisions in an uncertain world, that combination feels particularly powerful.

1 “Financial Planning and AI: Strategic Adoption.” eMoney, 2024.
2 “AI Financial Advisors and the Surprising Ways We Put Trust in AI.” MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy, 2026.